When Rates Rise, House Prices Fall and Rents Go Up
There is a thing people say when rates go up: good, housing will finally get cheaper.
It is half right, and the half it gets wrong is the half that matters if you rent.
Two Bank of Canada papers from this year measure what actually happens. Higher rates do push
house prices down. They also push rents up. Same policy, opposite directions, and which one
you feel depends entirely on which side of the ownership line you are standing on.
The national picture
The first paper isolates what happens when mortgage rates rise because of monetary policy, rather
than for some other reason. That distinction matters, and it is most of the work in the paper.
A one percentage point rise in mortgage rates lowers house prices by about 5 percent
after a year and 10 percent after two. That is the part everybody expects.
Over the same period the consumer price index for rent goes up by about 2 to 3
percent in the first year and 5 to 6 percent by year two. The authors are careful to say those rent
estimates are less statistically significant than the price estimates, and I will be equally careful:
the direction is well supported, the exact size less so.
The rent-to-price ratio, which is just the cost of renting measured against the cost of owning,
rises by around 18 percent after one year and 28 percent after two. Renting gets more expensive
relative to owning, even as owning gets cheaper to buy into.
Why rents go up when borrowing gets expensive
Two reasons, and the papers find evidence for both.
The first is that landlords have mortgages too. When financing costs rise, some of that gets
passed to tenants. The second is more interesting: people who would have bought stay renting
instead. They do not leave the housing market, they just queue in a different part of it, and that
pushes up demand for the exact thing they are now stuck in.
The paper tests this directly. Cities where first-time buyer mortgages fell the most six months
after a rate rise are the same cities where rents rose the most two years later. The would be buyers
became long term renters, and the rental market absorbed them.
Why Toronto gets hit hardest
This is where it stops being a national story.
The researchers split Canadian cities by how easily new housing gets built. In places where it is
hard to build, which they name as Toronto and Vancouver, the rent-to-price ratio
moves about 20 percent two years after a rate rise. In places where building is
easier, Winnipeg and Saskatoon among them, it moves about 5 percent.
Four times the effect, for the same national policy decision. Not because Torontonians borrow
differently, but because when demand shifts here, supply cannot move to meet it.
The population growth multiplier
The second paper adds the condition that explains why 2022 to 2024 felt so much worse than the
theory alone would suggest.
The pass through from mortgage costs into rents is not constant. When population growth sits near
its historical norm, higher financing costs barely reach rents at all. When population growth is
rapid, the same cost increase pushes rents up substantially more, because a tight rental market gives
landlords the pricing power to pass it on.
So the rate increases of the last few years did not land on a normal rental market. They landed on
an unusually tight one, and the two effects multiplied.
This is not an argument for or against any level of immigration, and the paper does not make one.
It measures a mechanism: cost increases reach prices more easily when demand is high. That is true
of rental housing and it is true of most other markets.
What this means if you are deciding something
- If you are renting and waiting for rates to fall before buying, understand what
you are paying to wait. In a falling rate environment the research implies the opposite pressures:
prices firm up, rent pressure eases. The window where owning looks cheapest relative to renting is
when rates are high, which is exactly when it feels least affordable. - If you own and are watching your value fall, the same mechanism that took value
off your house is putting pressure on rents. If you have a basement apartment or a rental property,
those two moves partly offset each other. - If you are a landlord, the research says your costs and your rents move
together, but not one for one and not instantly. The pass through depends on how tight your local
rental market actually is.
The uncomfortable conclusion in both papers is that the Bank cannot make housing cheaper for
everyone at once. Lowering rates helps buyers and hurts affordability. Raising them helps buyers on
price and hurts renters. There is no setting of the policy rate that is good news for everybody, and
anyone telling you otherwise is selling something.
Where This Comes From
This post draws on two Bank of Canada staff analytical papers: 2026-2, “Channels of Transmission: How Mortgage Rates Affect House Prices and Rents in Canada” (February 2026), and 2026-14, “The Impact of Mortgage Interest Costs on Rental Inflation Amid Population Growth” by Amina Enkhbold and Serdar Kabaca (April 2026). Both are free on the Bank of Canada website. City supply elasticity estimates come from Paixão (2021), cited in the first paper.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do higher interest rates make rent go up or down?
Why do rents rise when house prices fall?
Why is Toronto affected more than other Canadian cities?
Does population growth change how rate hikes affect rent?
Should I buy now or wait for lower rates?
Related Reading
- Mortgage Renewals in Canada
- Your Credit Card Slips Two Years Before Your Mortgage Does
- Ontario Landlords Are Selling
- GTA Real Estate Market Update
If you are weighing renting against buying right now and want the actual numbers for a specific neighbourhood rather than a national average, send me the area and I will put the comparison together. No obligation.