Your Property Assessment Is a 2016 Number, and That Is Not Good News
Every few months somebody shows me their property assessment and says the number is far too low,
and asks whether they should tell somebody.
No. And the reason why is the most useful thing to understand about property tax in Ontario.
Your assessment is a 2016 number
Ontario postponed its province-wide reassessment during the pandemic and has kept postponing it.
Assessments for the 2026 property tax year are still based on January 1, 2016 current
values.
Read that again. The value your property tax is calculated from is what your home was worth a
decade ago.
Your property tax is not your assessment multiplied by some universal rate. Your municipality decides how much money it needs, then sets a rate that raises it across the total assessed value of everything in the municipality. So what matters is not whether your assessment is low in absolute terms. It is whether your assessment is low relative to comparable properties. If every house on your street is assessed on the same stale 2016 basis, nobody has an advantage and your bill is unchanged. This is why ‘my assessment is way below market’ is not good news, not bad news, and not worth acting on by itself.
When an appeal is actually worth it
The question to ask is not “is my assessment lower than my home’s value.” It is “is my assessment
higher than it should be compared to similar homes assessed on the same date.”
That happens for real reasons: an error in the recorded square footage, a finished basement that
does not exist, a comparison to properties that are not genuinely comparable, or a lot classified
incorrectly.
The process, and the deadlines
What to actually do first, and it is free
Before filing anything, log in to MPAC’s own property portal and read your property profile. You
are entitled to see the details they hold about your home, and you can compare against similar
properties.
Most successful reconsiderations are not clever arguments. They are somebody noticing that MPAC
thinks the house has an extra bathroom, or four hundred more square feet than it does, or a finished
basement it has never had.
Do not use your assessment as a pricing guide, and do not let a buyer use it as one either. It
is a 2016 valuation on a mass appraisal basis. It was never intended to tell you what your home is
worth today, and in a market that has moved as much as this one has, it will not.
Deadlines here are strict and the process differs by property classification. Confirm your
dates on MPAC’s own site and on the Assessment Review Board’s, and consider professional help for
anything beyond a straightforward factual correction.
Where This Comes From
Written from MPAC guidance on the assessment cycle, Requests for Reconsideration and appeal deadlines, and Assessment Review Board filing information.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is my property assessment so much lower than my home’s value?
Will a lower assessment reduce my property taxes?
How do I appeal my property assessment in Ontario?
What makes an assessment appeal likely to succeed?
Should I use my assessment to price my home for sale?
Related Reading
- The Toronto Vacant Home Tax Trap for Buyers
- Closing Costs in Ontario
- Your Home Sells Tax Free, Until…
- What a Legal Basement Apartment Requires
If you want to know what your home is actually worth today rather than what a 2016 assessment says, that is a straightforward thing for me to put together, and it is the number that matters for every decision except your tax bill.